Phys. Ther. Korea 2021; 28(1): 72-76
Published online February 20, 2021
© Korean Research Society of Physical Therapy
Injury Prevention and Biomechanics Laboratory, Department of Physical Therapy, Yonsei University, Wonju, Korea
Background: A pressure ulcer is common in soft tissue over the greater trochanter (GT) in side-lying position, and sustained tissue deformation induced by the prolonged external force is a primary cause, which can be discussed with soft tissues’ viscoelastic properties (i.e., stress relaxation, creep response).
Objects: Using an automated hand-held indentation device, we measured the viscoelastic properties of soft tissue over the hip area, in order to examine how the properties are affected by site with respect to the GT.
Methods: Twenty participants (15 males and 5 females) who aged from 21 to 32 were participated. An automated hand-held indentation device was used to measure the stress relaxation time and creep response. Trials were acquired for three different locations with respect to the GT (i.e., right over the GT, 6 cm anterior or posterior to the GT). For each location, five trials were acquired and averaged for data analyses.
Results: Soft tissues’ stress relaxation time and creep response were associated with site (F = 23.98, p < 0.005; F = 24.09, p < 0.005; respectively). The stress relaxation time was greatest at posterior gluteal region (19.22 ± 2.49 ms), and followed by anterior region (15.39 ± 2.47 ms) and right over the GT (14.40 ± 3.18 ms). Similarly, creep response was greatest at posterior gluteal region (1.16 ± 0.14), and followed by anterior region (0.95 ± 0.14) and right over the GT (0.89 ± 0.18).
Conclusion: Our results showed that the stress relaxation and creep were greatest at the posterior gluteal region and least at right over the GT, indicating that the gluteal soft tissue is more protective to the prolonged external force, when compared to the trochanteric soft tissue. The results suggest that a risk of pressure ulcer over the GT may decrease with slightly posteriorly rotated side-lying position.
Keywords: Creep response, Pressure ulcer, Stress relaxation, Viscoelasticity
A pressure ulcer is common in nursing home residents. National Nursing Home Survey has shown that one of ten residents suffer from pressure-related injuries . As a result of pressure ulcer, several infectious complications may occur (i.e., cellulitis, bacteremia, and sepsis) and these can lead the residents to death. While prognosis of pressure ulcer isn’t bad, the risk of mortality of pressure ulcer can increase about 50% due to such complications [2-4].
A pressure ulcer is defined as an injury to the skin and underlying soft tissues over a bony prominence, that develops as a result of prolonged external load. Body sites vulnerable to the pressure ulcer include hip, back, ankle, and buttock, highly depending on body positions. In particular, soft tissue over the greater trochanter (GT) is the most vulnerable in side-lying position .
Research has shown that pressure ulcer is initiated by ischemia, where cellular metabolism declines due to limited oxygen supply [6-8], and develops through ischemia-reperfusion injury or reoxygenation injury, where soft tissue damage occurs due to inflammatory reaction [9,10]. Furthermore, Ceelen et al.  conducted experiments with an animal model to measure soft tissue damage after 2 hour-long compression. They found that a positive relationship between soft tissue damage and tissue deformation induced by the prolonged compression, suggesting that sustained tissue deformation would be a risk factor of pressure ulcer.
Stress relaxation and creep response are unique, time-dependent phenomena observed when biological materials (i.e., muscle, ligament, tendon, cartilage or skin) are subject to the external load (i.e., compression or pulling force). The phenomena occurs because the biological materials are viscoelastic due to water and collagen content inside, and determine the speed and degree of tissue deformation. The stress relaxation is an ability to decrease internal stress caused by compression, and the greater stress relaxation time materials have, the more resistant to redistribution of the stress (thereby more time is required to deform, lowering the risk of pressure ulcer). Similarly, the creep time can be defined as the time it takes to reach final equilibrium strain when the constant load is applied to the tissue, and materials with greater creep time are likely to have greater resistance to deformation, lowering the pressure ulcer risk. These viscoelastic properties have been commonly used in animal studies to address pressure ulcer [12-14]. Technology is available to measure these properties by analyzing responses of soft tissue to small tapping force. When the tapping force is applied, soft tissue vibrates with alteration of compression and expansion. This oscillation decays over time, and the speed and depth of compression (or oscillation) depend on the viscoelastic properties of soft tissue. By analyzing this time series of deformation, velocity and acceleration data, stress relaxation and creep response of soft tissue can be estimated.
Against this background, we measured stress relaxation and creep response of soft tissue over the hip area as biomarkers of pressure ulcer. We then examined how these are affected by sites with respect to the GT.
Twenty individuals (15 males and 5 females [aged between 21 and 32]) were recruited. Demographic information is provided in Table 1. Exclusion criteria included musculoskeletal injuries, including but not limited to, abrasion, laceration, burn, fractures, contusion over the hip area. All participants provided signed consent forms. The study protocol has been approved by the Institutional Review Board in Yonsei University Mirae campus.
Participants lay sideways exposing the skin of the lateral aspect of the hip (Figure 1A). With respect to the GT, three points with an interval of 6 cm were marked on the skin via a water-soluble pen (Figure 1B). We then used an automated hand-held indentation device (MyotonPRO; Myoton AS, Tallinn, Estonia) to measure viscoelastic properties of soft tissue over the three points. The device recorded vibration of soft tissue after applying a low taping force (0.4 N) to the skin, and calculated stress relaxation time and a ratio of “stress relaxation time” to “time to cause maximum deformation” (creep response). Measurement of coefficient of variation (CV) of the device provided in the manual shows that the CV of stress relaxation and creep were 1.2% and 1.5%, respectively. Furthermore, several research studies support accuracy and repeatability of the methodology of the device [15-17]. Two trained physiotherapists (practiced at least 1 hour for measurements) measured the participants’ right hip and five trials were acquired for each location (tap time was 15 ms with 1 ms intervals) and averaged for data analyses.
Repeated measures ANOVA was used to test whether the outcome variables were associated with site with respect to the GT (3 levels). When a main effect was significant, pairwise comparisons were conducted using Bonferroni correction with alpha level at 0.017 (0.05/3).
Stress relaxation was associated with site (F = 23.98, p < 0.005). The stress relaxation time differed across three sites with respect to the GT, being greatest (19.2 ± 2.49 ms) at the posterior gluteal region and least (14.4 ± 3.18 ms) at right over the GT (Figure 2A).
Similar trends were observed for creep response, and creep response was associated with site (F = 24.09, p < 0.005). The creep response differed across three sites over the hip region, being greatest (1.16 ± 0.14) at the posterior gluteal region and least (0.89 ± 0.18) at right over the GT (Figure 2B).
The purpose of this study was to examine whether the viscoelastic properties (stress relaxation, creep) were affected by site, in order to discuss a risk of pressure ulcer with side-lying position. We found that the stress relaxation time and creep response were greatest at posterior gluteal region and least at right over the GT. This indicates that the gluteal soft tissue is more resistant to tissue deformation induced by the prolonged external force when compared to the trochanteric soft tissue, suggesting that a risk of pressure ulcer over the GT may decrease with slightly posteriorly rotated side-lying position. This finding supports the repositioning guidelines for the individuals who are bedridden . The guidelines suggest side-lying position with body rotation 30 degrees posterior would reduce the incidence of pressure ulcer in hospitalized patients when compared to side-lying position with a pelvis perpendicular to the horizontal line, where the GT contacts the bed directly .
A potential reason why the viscoelastic properties differed across sites might be explained, in part, by varying properties and composition of soft tissue over the hip area [6,20]. The soft tissue may include skin, fat, muscle and fascia, and each tissue layer has different viscoelastic properties (i.e., muscle is more viscoelastistic than fat). Furthermore, distribution (thickness) of each layer depends on site with respect to the GT (more muscle and adipose tissue in posterior [gluteal] region than in anterior or right over the GT). This variability results in changes in soft tissue properties over the hip area.
Our study has several limitations. First, the stress relaxation and creep response is time-dependent, but temperature-dependent as well. However, we did not consider room or participants’ skin temperature during data collection. Second, previous systematic reviews showed that age, mobility and activity levels are risk factors of pressure ulcer [21,22]. However, these were not considered in this study. Future studies should include these factors for better understanding of how the viscoelastic properties over the hip area are affected by sites.
The stress relaxation time and creep response were greatest at the posterior gluteal region and least right over the GT, indicating that the gluteal soft tissue is more resistant to tissue deformation induced by the prolonged external load, when compared to the trochanteric soft tissue. The results suggest that a risk of pressure ulcer over the GT may decrease with slightly posteriorly rotated side-lying position.
This study was supported by the “Brain Korea 21 FOUR Project”, the Korean Research Foundation for Department of Physical Therapy in the Graduate School of Yonsei University. Authors thank Seohyun Kim for her help in data collection.
No potential conflict of interest relevant to this article was reported.
Conceptualization: KL, WJC. Investigation: KL, SK. Supervision: WJC. Writing - original draft: KL. Writing - review & editing: KL, WJC.